GOP infighting over SAVE America Act leaves critical legislation in limbo

Opinion>Opinions - Lindsey's Lens The views expressed by contributors are their own and not the view of The Hill GOP infighting over SAVE America Act leaves critical legislation in limbo Comments: by Lindsey Granger, opinion contributor - 07/01/26 1:51 PM ET Comments: Link copied by Lindsey Granger, opinion contributor - 07/01/26 1:51 PM ET Comments: Link copied

NOW PLAYING

For the second week in a row, House Republicans have ground their own agenda to a halt over President Trump’s SAVE America Act. This time, 14 Republicans voted against advancing the annual defense authorization bill — legislation Congress passes every year to fund and set policy for the military — because it didn’t include the president’s voting bill. The procedural vote failed, leaving even this must-pass legislation in limbo.

Here are the facts: The House has already passed the SAVE America Act three different times. The problem isn’t the House. The problem is the Senate, where the bill doesn’t have the votes to overcome the filibuster. Even many Senate Republicans have acknowledged that political reality. Yet instead of accepting it, the White House and House conservatives keep looking for new ways to force the issue.

Over the past several weeks, Trump has tried to use one bill after another as leverage to force Congress to pass the SAVE America Act. First it was a bipartisan housing bill. Then it was renewing FISA. Now it’s the annual defense bill.

But that strategy has also created a civil war inside the House Republican conference. Some conservatives say Speaker Mike Johnson promised them he’d attach the SAVE Act to the defense bill. When that didn’t happen, they revolted and blocked the legislation from moving forward.

The frustration boiled over after the vote. According to Punchbowl News reporter Catherine Leffert, Congressman Max Miller said of Speaker Johnson, “There’s one common problem here. It’s always been one person, and for someone who’s got the holiest tongue in the world, he lies more than anyone I’ve ever met.”

In other words, this wasn’t just Republicans fighting Democrats. It was Republicans fighting each other over how far they’re willing to go to force a bill that still doesn’t appear to have enough votes.

Supporters argue the SAVE America Act is necessary to ensure only U.S. citizens vote in federal elections, but federal law has prohibited noncitizen voting in federal elections for decades, and documented cases remain exceedingly rare. It makes you question why there is this much emphasis on legislation that could potentially make registration harder for millions of eligible Americans who don’t have immediate access to documents like passports or birth certificates; the legislation could also create major administrative burdens for election officials.

Congress isn’t just debating election policy anymore. It’s increasingly using unrelated, must-pass bills as leverage in a fight that doesn’t have the votes to succeed. And when defense funding, housing policy and intelligence programs all become bargaining chips for the same bill — a bill the president has described as a “national emergency” despite voting by noncitizens being a non-issue — naturally, folks are going to ask if this is about protecting elections or something else.

Lindsey Granger is a NewsNation contributor and co-host of The Hill’s commentary show “Rising.” This column is an edited transcription of her on-air commentary.

Add as preferred source on Google Tags defense authorization Donald Trump FISA housing bill Max Miller Mike Johnson SAVE America Act Senate Republicans

Comments: Link copied